The QCA are currently reviewing 2 elements of the QCA silk process:
- should you list ALL substantive cases for the 2-3 year period and ALL assessors to avoid “cherry picking”
- wider character and integrity reviews
The deadline for comments is 31 July 2018 and changes may then be introduced for the 2019 competition.
Response contact details available from the QCA website – linked here. Scroll down to “Potential Changes” section on Home page.
Summary of the silk process this year, that remains primarily to identify excellence in advocacy:
- The deadline is 5pm on Wed 28th March 2018
- You can now use cases going back 3 yearswithout needing to justify why – they would prefer 2 years as memories fade beyond 2 years, but you can use 3 year cases if necessary. They suggest you avoid using cases beyond 3 years, but you can if you justify it
- You need 12 cases, if possible, of your most important cases in last 2/3 years. Worth checking in advance with QCA if aiming to use fewer than 12 cases, to pass your reasons why past them first, but there seems to be more flexibility if you have a strong reason and don’t have cases that go back beyond 3 years either. Toning down of language and measures for substantive nature of cases
- Assessors:Name at least 8, and up to 12, judges – Name 6 practitioners – Name at least 4, and up to 6, clients – so aim for 8-6-4, no advantage having more Js or Cs
- Need good reason if don’t have the number of assessors (8/6/4) and indeed the form includes a tick box to show you know that your application will be materially affected if you have significantly fewer than 8/6/4 assessors
- They specifically mention opponents as useful practitioner assessors this year – especially if they are QCs
- Avoid having majority of practitioner assessors from your own chambers/firm
- The Narrative Description of practice has 4,000 characters to describe your practice and justify your 12 cases
- There remains a limit of 2,750 charactersper competency in the self-assessment – this is about 400-450 words MAX
- Of particular importance in oral advocacy is XX and X-in-C, if your practice encompasses this
- In the assessor section, section H, there are 1,000 characters to describe your cases, and 3 boxes for cases they have seen you in
- If you see a case at first instance and on appeal, only list the case once – but OK if case covers substantially different issues
- If you are using a case that is on-going, it needs to have had a sufficiently substantive hearing or development to be included – and don’t have too many on-going cases
- You can send skeletons to assessors in advance when you ask them if they are prepared to be an assessor and we would encourage you to do so
- Diversity section can explicitly use sitting/arbitrator examples now as it can relate to your wider professional life
- Integrity – there is normally no need to complete this section
- There is wider clarification of the relevant jurisdictionsin Part One of the Guidance – make sure you ring the QCA if you have Qs about jurisdictions such as NI, IoM, international arbitrations etc
- Interviewswill be held in London and Manchester mid September to early October – results will be announced in December 2018
- Test saving and using the 69 page pdf version of the application form before you start adding major text so you know that it works – you will need Adobe Reader DC, XI or X to complete it – if you cannot get it to work, contact QCA asap so that your problem can be resolved sooner rather than later
- Fees are the same as last year – £1,800+VAT to apply (those who earn <£60K are entitled to a concessionary applic rate of £900+VAT) – then there is the £3,000+VAT appointment fee if you are successful
- Sir Alex Allan now chairs the panel and Rachel Langdale QC, Penny Reed QC and Monisha Shah have joined the panel – there is a judicial panel vacancy
We would also recommend that you read the reports from the last competition including the detailed review of the competencies via this link.
Get in touch asap if you want to get a first draft date in the diary, as slots fill up very quickly.
And good luck everyone.
The Silk 2018 competition has just launched – deadline is 28 March. We will update changes to the process this year once we have had a chance to read through the Guidelines etc.
If you have arranged contact with Kate, Gwyn, Ann or Simon, then you might want to start planning first draft meetings in their diaries, to set effective deadlines for 28 March submission.
Here we go …………… and Happy Valentine’s Day ………..
The Recorder competition has now launched. 100 vacancies (70 crime; 30 family).
- Register online by 8 Feb
- Online qualifying test 15 Feb
- Online scenario test 7 March
- If get through these two online sifts then submit application form by 20 April
- Next sift is a Telephone Assessment 4-23 May
- Interview and role play 6-26 July
Link to JAC website for further details.
The QCA have announced:
“It is expected that the next competition will open on Thursday 16th February 2017, with a closure time and date of 5pm on Thursday 30th March 2017. The 2017 Guidance to Applicants and the 2017 Application Form will be available from the opening date. These dates still await confirmation.”
Link to QCA website
Results of the recent survey for Women at the Bar are now available – over 1300 women at the Bar responded (that’s about a quarter of all women at the Bar) – sad to see that 2 out of 5 respondents have had experience of harassment and discrimination though.
Link to report available below.
Makes interesting reading for those determined to help retain quality talent at the Bar.
Diversity & Inclusion is an important issue for law firms. There have been some improvements, yet the statistics show that most talented women are still choosing to leave firms and make alternative career choices. Overall, still only about 20% of partners are women.
Are firms really committed to change or are they just ticking boxes? These and other relevant questions are addressed in this short survey for women in law firms to see what firms need to do to have more women in senior leadership positions.
We’d love to hear from you. It takes just 2 minutes to complete. It’s totally confidential. You can get the results.